|
Amazon.com's
Best of 2001
Editors Art Spiegelman and Françoise Mouly have packed so much top-notch
talent into this flabbergastingly funny all-ages comic collection that
you'll have a terrible time deciding what to read first. Just as with the
previous Little Lit book, Folklore & Fairy Tale Funnies, you'll find
some of the most hilarious, intelligent, and diverse short comics around
inside these pages: Maurice Sendak's omnivorous infant gobbles up everything
in sight in "Cereal Baby Keller"; David Sedaris pairs up with
Ian Falconer to define true cuteness; "Where's Waldo?" creator
Martin Handford searches for old socks; Paul Auster (yes, that Paul Auster)
and Jacques de Loustal's offering follows a man who's found he's disappeared;
Crockett Johnson (Harold and the Purple Crayon) brings back the beginning
of his classic '40s strip, "Barnaby" (a favorite of Duke Ellington
and Dorothy Parker, among others); and Spiegelman himself takes on "The
Several Selves of Selby Sheldrake." And that's not even the half of
it. This downright quirky collection will charm comic fans of all ages--and,
no doubt, make fans out of those who weren't already. Even the endpapers
are funny, thanks to Kaz of "Underworld." (All ages after 9 or
so) --Paul Hughes
From Publishers Weekly
Once upon a time, picture books got parental approval and pulp comics were
a sneaky pleasure. In this sequel to Little Lit, Spiegelman and Mouly create
a hybrid of the two that may well appeal to oddballs of all ages. Charles
Burns leads the charge with his high-impact cover image of an alien reading
a boy's space comics. The alien has kewpie-doll eyes and a puppyish nose,
but its sinewy muscles and lurid green skin pack a perverse threat. In
the endpapers, which suggest a pulp-mag correspondence course, Underworld
author Kaz offers "Strange Cartoon Lessons" cards ("Bad
at drawing legs? Put your character behind a desk"). After these engaging
diversions, the treasury trots out stories from the funny-ha-ha to the
funny-strange, many dealing with secret identities. Spiegelman invents
a boy whose moods materialize as clones; Jules Feiffer's anxiety-prone
child gets "Trapped in a Comic Book"; and Jacques de Loustal
and Paul Auster collaborate on a melancholy Kafka-esque noir tale. As the
title promises, some of the material is disturbing. Maurice Sendak's punny "Cereal
Baby Keller" reprises his violent sketch of a ravenous baby that eats
its parents; Ian Falconer and David Sedaris team for a gruesome story of
a monster that flips inside-out because "Real beauty is on the inside." More
benign picks include an exhausting maze game by Lewis Trondheim, and Barbara
McClintock's buoyant story of a shadow that breaks loose. A lengthy reprint
of Crockett Johnson's Barnaby strip seems misplaced here, but its airy
layout and square panels are a strong counterpoint to the condensed, offbeat
material. This compendium, with its stellar group of comix and picture-book
literati, revels in its dark side and suggests that "strange kids" are
the mainstream. All ages.
Copyright 2001 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
From School Library Journal
Grades 3-6--As they did in Little Lit: Folklore and Fairy Tale Funnies
(HarperCollins, 2000), Spiegelman and Mouly have drawn on the talents of
major cartoonists and illustrators, who render their art in comic-book
format to produce a collection of truly bizarre and intriguing tales. There
are contributions from Maurice Sendak, Ian Falconer, Jules Feiffer, the
late Crockett Johnson, and a host of others. The stories run the gamut
from the mildly quirky-such as Barbara McClintock's fanciful tale of a
shadow that takes off on its own-to darker, more disturbing selections
such as Jacques de Loustal and Paul Auster's "The Day I Disappeared," in
which a man separated from his physical being must rescue himself from
drowning. The stories all possess a sharp intelligence and unique imagination,
and the innovative use of an old format will entice both reluctant and
enthusiastic readers to return again and again. Give this to kids who love
Jon Scieszka's type of humor and are ready for the next step.
Grace Oliff, Ann Blanche Smith School, Hillsdale, NJ
Copyright 2002 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
From Booklist
Gr. 4-up. In this follow-up to their excellent Little Lit: Folklore & Fairy
Tale Funnies (2000), Spiegelman and Mouly offer another collection of wildly
original graphic stories from well-known contributors. This volume emphasizes
the surreal. There's Spiegelman's bizarre story of a boy whose multiple
personalities appear when he picks his nose. And there's Maurice Sendak's "Baby
Keller," an omnivorous man-child who eats everything, including his
parents. Teens (and adults) will like the stylish, ironic seek-and-find
that directs readers to search for "Hiccupping Ghost" and "Big
Idea Stuck in a Tree"; other stories, such as Ian Falconer and David
Sedaris' hilarious "Pretty Ugly," will delight younger children.
A few entries, such as Crockett Johnson's tale, seem out of place among
the other edgy choices. But whether the stories are elegant fantasies,
grotesque horror, or gross-out humor, they will excite readers of many
ages with their range of styles and visual possibilities. Gillian Engberg
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved |
|
|
|
|
|